There’s a certain romance to the Old West, a raw-edged nostalgia for a time of cowboys, cattle drives, and six-shooters. For many of us, that fascination translates into a desire for firearms that echo that era. But the reality of owning, maintaining, and finding a place to shoot a genuine 19th-century revolver is a significant hurdle. We turn to CO2 replicas, hoping to capture a piece of that history for backyard plinking or skill development. Yet, so often, the experience falls flat. We’re handed lightweight plastic toys that feel hollow and disappointing, lacking the heft and mechanical soul of the originals. This search for authenticity, for the cold, solid feel of steel and the satisfying mechanical click of a single-action hammer, is what leads many enthusiasts to a crossroads, wondering if a truly faithful replica even exists. This is the exact void the Remington RR1875 CO2 Pellet/BB Revolver aims to fill.
- WESTERN-STYLE DESIGN - Classic Remington 1875 replica
- CO2-POWERED - Single action (CO2 not included)
What to Consider Before Buying a CO2 Replica Air Pistol
A CO2 replica air pistol is more than just an item; it’s a key solution for accessible, affordable, and safe firearms practice and historical appreciation. It solves the problem of needing a dedicated range, expensive ammunition, and extensive licensing to enjoy the mechanical function and handling characteristics of a classic firearm. The main benefits are profound: they allow for skill development in sight alignment, trigger control, and safe handling in a low-cost, low-impact environment like a backyard. For collectors and history buffs, they offer a tangible connection to iconic designs without the immense cost and responsibility of owning a genuine antique.
The ideal customer for this type of product is someone who values realism, tactile feedback, and the historical significance of the design. This includes backyard plinkers looking for a more engaging experience, historical reenactors needing a safe prop, or firearm owners who want a tool for inexpensive practice. It might not be suitable for those who prioritize raw power, long-range precision for competition, or a semi-automatic action for rapid firing. For those users, a modern, performance-oriented pellet pistol or a semi-automatic BB gun might be a better fit.
Before investing, consider these crucial points in detail:
- Weight & Materials: The feel of an air pistol is paramount for a replica. A full-metal frame, like that found in the Remington RR1875, provides a realistic weight and balance that plastic models simply cannot replicate. At 2.3 pounds, it feels substantial and real in the hand, which is critical for both training muscle memory and the overall enjoyment of the piece. Consider if you want something that feels like a tool or a toy.
- Action Type & Realism: The action dictates the shooting experience. A single-action revolver requires the hammer to be manually cocked for every shot, just like the historical original. This is a deliberate, methodical process that many purists love. It’s different from a double-action revolver or a semi-automatic pistol. Look for functional parts like a loading gate and an extractor rod to enhance the authentic experience.
- Ammunition Versatility: Many CO2 pistols are dedicated to either BBs or pellets. A model that can shoot both, like the Remington RR1875 CO2 Pellet/BB Revolver, offers incredible flexibility. Steel BBs are inexpensive and great for plinking at cans, while lead pellets generally offer superior accuracy for target shooting. Having separate, dedicated cartridges for each type is a huge plus, ensuring proper fit and performance.
- Ease of Use & Maintenance: Consider how the CO2 cartridge is loaded. A system with an integrated tool, often hidden within the grip, is a fantastic design feature that prevents you from losing a crucial component. The loading process for ammunition should also be straightforward. While these guns are generally low-maintenance, the ability to do a basic field strip for cleaning, as some users have noted is possible with this model, is a bonus for long-term reliability.
Understanding these factors will help you choose a CO2 replica that not only looks the part but delivers an experience that is deeply satisfying and true to its heritage.
While the Remington RR1875 CO2 Pellet/BB Revolver is an excellent choice, it’s always wise to see how it stacks up against the competition. For a broader look at all the top models, we highly recommend checking out our complete, in-depth guide:
- 15-Shot, .177 Caliber Bb Air Pistol
- 177 cal. BB Pistol with a smooth bore steel barrel
- Semi-automatic; .50 Caliber; 385 fps; 7.32" long
First Impressions: Unboxing a Piece of the Old West
From the moment the box is opened, it’s clear the Remington RR1875 CO2 Pellet/BB Revolver is something special. There’s no flimsy plastic shell here. Lifting the revolver reveals its surprising and deeply satisfying heft. At 2.3 pounds, its full-metal construction immediately communicates quality and authenticity. The nickel finish is bright and eye-catching, providing a beautiful contrast to the faux ivory grips. These grips, while not real ivory, have a pleasant texture and appearance that perfectly complements the classic Western aesthetic. In the hand, the balance is excellent, feeling just like you’d imagine a real 1875 revolver would. We were immediately drawn to the functional components: the hammer cocks back with a solid, authoritative series of clicks. The loading gate snaps open and closed with precision. The ejector rod moves smoothly in its housing. Included in the box are two sets of six cartridges—one set for .177 caliber pellets and another for 4.5mm BBs. This dual-ammo capability, right out of the box, is a significant value and a major point in its favor. You can explore its full feature set and authentic design to see just how detailed this replica is.
What We Like
- Superb, realistic weight and feel thanks to its full-metal construction.
- Dual-ammo capability, firing both pellets and BBs with included dedicated cartridges.
- Authentic single-action mechanism with functional loading gate and ejector rod.
- Cleverly designed CO2 piercing tool integrated directly into the removable grip panel.
- Beautiful nickel finish and faux ivory grips create a stunning visual replica.
Limitations
- Can be prone to jamming if fired too quickly, especially with certain BB types.
- Some user reports mention minor quality control issues, like barrel wobble, out of the box.
A Deep Dive into the Remington RR1875’s Performance
A beautiful replica is one thing, but a great air pistol must perform. We spent considerable time on the range putting the Remington RR1875 through its paces, evaluating everything from its handling and realism to its accuracy with both ammunition types. This is where the story of this revolver truly unfolds, revealing a character that is both deeply rewarding and possessed of a few notable quirks.
Authenticity and Realism: It’s All in the Feel
The single greatest strength of the Remington RR1875 CO2 Pellet/BB Revolver is its commitment to realism. This isn’t just a visual replica; it’s a tactile one. The 2.3-pound weight is the first thing you notice, and it’s a game-changer. It eliminates any notion of this being a toy and forces you to handle it with the respect a real firearm commands. One user perfectly captured this, noting how other CO2 pistols at his Old West-themed party felt “mainly plastic and light,” but the Remington impressed every single person who held it with its substantial weight and action. We wholeheartedly agree. The experience begins when you thumb back the hammer. The four distinct clicks as it travels to full cock are mechanically crisp and deeply satisfying. This single-action operation forces a slower, more deliberate style of shooting that enhances precision and connects you to the historical shooting process.
Loading the revolver further deepens the immersive experience. You open the loading gate on the right side of the frame, which allows the cylinder to spin freely. You then load each of the six cartridges one by one, just as a cowboy would have done on the plains. After firing, you can open the gate again and use the functional, spring-loaded ejector rod under the barrel to push each spent cartridge out. It’s this dedication to functional detail that sets the RR1875 apart. As one owner mentioned, “Very, very realistic weight, feel and action. I love this piece.” It’s so realistic, in fact, that another user bought it specifically to use as a perfect model for crafting custom leather holsters. The nickel finish is lustrous and durable, and while the faux ivory grips are plastic, they are well-executed and comfortable, even for those with larger hands. This isn’t a prop; it’s a functional piece of history brought to life by CO2.
Dual-Ammo Versatility: Pellets for Precision, BBs for Fun
The decision to include two full sets of cartridges—six for pellets and six for BBs—is a masterstroke by Crosman. This immediately doubles the utility of the revolver. For casual plinking, popping cans, or just enjoying the sound of steel on steel, the BB cartridges are perfect. BBs are generally cheaper and loading them is slightly faster. However, as one user rightly pointed out, you must “not fire the gun too quickly.” We confirmed this in our testing; attempting to “fan” the hammer and fire rapidly can lead to BBs jamming in the barrel, which is a nuisance to clear. We also found, as another shooter did, that ammo choice matters. Hornady Black Diamond BBs cycled flawlessly, whereas other brands caused issues. This is a common quirk in many BB guns and is easily managed with smart ammo selection and a more measured firing pace.
Switching to the pellet cartridges transforms the revolver’s character. Pellets, being softer lead and diabolo-shaped, are inherently more accurate. In our tests at 10 yards, the groups tightened considerably with pellets. We used RWS 7gr Meisterkugeln pellets, and the results were impressive for a smoothbore pistol with fixed sights. One user shared this exact experience, stating they were “amazed at the accuracy” with these pellets and that the revolver shot them directly to the point of aim. This is a crucial point for anyone considering this pistol for more than just casual fun. The ability to switch to pellets gives it a genuine training and target-shooting capability. The smoothbore barrel might give purists pause, but as the same user wisely noted, in a CO2 pistol with a barrel of this length, the difference between a smoothbore and a rifled barrel is often negligible for practical accuracy. This dual-system is a feature that truly sets it apart, offering two distinct shooting experiences in one package.
On the Range: CO2 Management and Shooting Experience
Getting the Remington RR1875 ready to shoot is brilliantly simple. The left-side faux ivory grip panel pops off easily, without tools, to reveal the CO2 chamber. The real genius here is the integrated hex tool built right into the inside of the grip panel itself. This is a fantastic piece of design that solves the age-old problem of misplacing the proprietary Allen key that most other CO2 guns require. We found this to be a huge plus, echoed by a user who called it “a big plus in my mind as well.” You simply drop in a 12-gram CO2 cartridge, use the integrated tool to tighten the piercing screw until you hear a faint hiss, and you’re ready to go. The seal is solid, and we experienced no CO2 leaks during our extensive testing.
In terms of power, we got a consistent 50-60 effective shots per CO2 cartridge before the velocity began to drop off noticeably. This is quite respectable for a full-metal revolver of this size and weight. The trigger is a pure single-action trigger. After the hammer is cocked, the pull is light, short, and surprisingly crisp, which contributes greatly to its accuracy potential. The sights are period-correct—a simple blade in the front and a notch cut into the top of the frame in the rear. They are non-adjustable, but our model was regulated well, hitting point-of-aim at 10 yards, particularly with the aforementioned pellets. While it might not be a competition target pistol, it is more than accurate enough for thrilling backyard sessions and skill practice. The combination of the simple, effective CO2 system and the quality of the shooting experience makes the Remington RR1875 CO2 Pellet/BB Revolver an absolute joy to operate.
What Other Users Are Saying
The general consensus among users is overwhelmingly positive, with most praise centering on the revolver’s stunning realism. One owner, who bought it for an Old West-themed party, noted that every single guest who handled it was impressed by its “weight, feel, and action,” especially when compared to the lighter, plastic models others had. Another stated simply, “This particular piece is very nice. I honestly can find very little to no faults with this one.” The dual-ammo capability is another frequently lauded feature, seen as a significant bonus that adds versatility for different types of shooting.
However, the feedback isn’t without its critiques, which provides a balanced view. A recurring minor issue seems to be occasional quality control inconsistencies from the factory. One user reported their revolver arrived with some damage to the tip of the barrel, causing a slight wobble, though it didn’t leak CO2 and still worked well. The most common performance-related complaint is the tendency for the gun to jam if fired too rapidly, a point we confirmed in our own testing. As one reviewer advised, “make sure to not fire the gun to quickly.” This feedback is crucial, as it sets realistic expectations: this is a revolver meant for deliberate, paced shooting, not rapid-fire action.
How the Remington RR1875 Stacks Up Against the Competition
While the Remington RR1875 carves out a fantastic niche for itself, it’s important to see how it compares to other popular options in the air pistol market, especially those with different designs and purposes.
1. Sig Sauer 1911 Spartan CO2 Air Pistol
- SIG SAUER AIR PISTOL - The original that started it all - a Classic .45ACP handgun is now available in a BB pistol; The 1911 Spartan air pistol has CO2 Operating System and an ambidextrous manual...
- SEMI-AUTOMATIC CO2 POWERED - The SIG AIR line of BB pistols feature CO2- powered duplicates of the most desired SIG SAUER centerfire pistols in a 4.5mm BB platform for the ability to train anywhere,...
The Sig Sauer 1911 Spartan represents a completely different philosophy. Where the Remington celebrates 19th-century revolver design, the Spartan is a faithful replica of a modern, iconic semi-automatic pistol. It features a full-metal frame, realistic blowback action, and a 16-round stick magazine. A shooter would prefer the Sig Sauer if their primary interest is in modern military firearms, tactical training, or the convenience of a semi-auto action with a higher capacity. The blowback provides a more dynamic recoil impulse than the Remington. However, it lacks the Old West charm and the unique pellet/BB versatility of the RR1875’s cartridge system.
2. Gamo P-25 air Pistol
The Gamo P-25 is a performance-focused air pistol that prioritizes function over form. While it also features blowback, its design is modern and utilitarian, with a polymer frame and a focus on pellet-shooting accuracy from its rifled steel barrel. The Gamo uses a unique 16-round rotary clip system (8 rounds on each end). A shooter might choose the Gamo P-25 if their goal is pure target shooting performance in a semi-automatic platform, and they aren’t concerned with historical realism. It offers a faster rate of fire and potentially better pellet accuracy due to the rifled barrel, but it cannot match the authentic weight, feel, and immersive single-action experience of the Remington RR1875 CO2 Pellet/BB Revolver.
3. Daisy Powerline 415 CO2 Air Pistol
The Daisy Powerline 415 exists at the opposite end of the spectrum from the Remington RR1875. This is a budget-friendly, entry-level BB pistol designed for simple, casual fun. It features a lightweight polymer frame, a 21-round built-in magazine, and a semi-automatic action. The Daisy is an excellent choice for a beginner, a younger shooter (with supervision), or someone who wants an inexpensive “plinker” without any pretense of realism or historical accuracy. It’s easy to use and offers a high shot capacity. However, it completely lacks the full-metal construction, authentic weight, functional realism, and dual-ammo capability that make the Remington RR1875 a premium enthusiast’s piece.
Our Final Verdict: Is the Remington RR1875 the Right Revolver for You?
After extensive testing and careful consideration of user feedback, our verdict is clear: the Remington RR1875 CO2 Pellet/BB Revolver is an outstanding success in achieving its primary goal. It delivers an incredibly authentic, satisfying, and immersive Old West shooting experience. Its full-metal construction and realistic weight are class-leading, providing a tactile satisfaction that plastic replicas simply cannot touch. The inclusion of separate cartridges for both pellets and BBs makes it exceptionally versatile, transitioning from a fun plinker to a surprisingly accurate target shooter in seconds. The clever integration of the CO2 tool in the grip is a final, thoughtful touch that elevates the entire user experience.
We would wholeheartedly recommend this air pistol to any historical firearms enthusiast, backyard plinker who values realism, or anyone looking for a beautiful and functional replica for display and enjoyment. While it’s not designed for rapid-fire competition and requires a deliberate hand to avoid jams, its strengths far outweigh these minor quirks. If you’ve been searching for a CO2 revolver that feels less like a toy and more like a time machine, your search is over. To experience this exceptional piece of replica engineering for yourself, we highly recommend you check the latest price and availability and bring a piece of the frontier home.
Last update on 2025-10-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API