There’s a unique satisfaction that comes from setting up a few tin cans in the backyard on a quiet afternoon. It’s a simple pleasure—a test of focus and a throwback to a simpler time. For years, I’ve sought the ideal sidearm for this exact purpose: something reliable, affordable to shoot, and easy for friends and family to handle. The search often leads to a classic dilemma: do you choose the affordable, rapid-fire fun of a BB pistol, or the superior accuracy of a pellet gun? Each has its merits, but owning and maintaining two separate pistols for casual plinking always felt like overkill. The dream was to find one gun that could do both without significant compromises. This is the exact problem the Gamo Pellet/Steel BB Air Pistols, also known as the P-27, promises to solve. It enters the market with a compelling pitch: dual-ammo capability in a straightforward, budget-friendly package. The question is, does it deliver on that promise, or are the compromises too great?
What to Consider Before Buying a CO2 Air Pistol
A CO2 air pistol is more than just a recreational item; it’s a key solution for developing marksmanship skills, engaging in backyard plinking, or even managing small pests, all without the noise and regulations associated with traditional firearms. The primary benefit is accessibility—they are relatively inexpensive to purchase and shoot, powered by readily available 12-gram CO2 cartridges. They offer a safe and controlled environment to practice sight alignment, trigger control, and firearm safety. For many, they are the gateway to the world of shooting sports, providing hours of enjoyment for a minimal investment.
The ideal customer for this type of product is someone looking for casual, low-cost recreational shooting. This includes beginners wanting to learn the fundamentals, families looking for a safe outdoor activity, or anyone who simply enjoys the challenge of knocking over targets. However, a non-blowback, smooth-bore pistol like this might not be suitable for those who prioritize realism and simulated recoil for training purposes, or for competitors who require the pinpoint accuracy of a high-end, rifled-barrel pellet pistol. For those users, blowback models or dedicated single-shot pellet pistols would be more appropriate alternatives.
Before investing, consider these crucial points in detail:
- Dimensions & Weight: How a pistol feels in your hand is paramount. The Gamo P-27’s dimensions (7″L x 1.5″W) and weight (1.32 lbs) make it a full-sized pistol. Consider if this size is comfortable for your hands and if the weight provides a sense of substance without causing fatigue during longer shooting sessions.
- Performance & Ammunition Type: Performance is a balance of velocity (FPS), accuracy, and capacity. Dual-ammo capability is a huge plus for versatility, but it often comes with a smooth-bore barrel, which is excellent for BBs but less precise for pellets. Understand this trade-off: are you prioritizing pellet accuracy or the fun of shooting both types? A 16-round capacity is quite generous for this class and minimizes reloading time.
- Materials & Durability: The debate between polymer and metal frames is ongoing. Polymer, as used in the Gamo Pellet/Steel BB Air Pistols, is lightweight, durable, and resistant to the elements. Full-metal pistols offer more realistic weight and heft but can be more expensive. A key factor here is the internal mechanism and barrel—the P-27 features a metal barrel, which is a good sign for longevity.
- Action Type & Realism: The action determines the shooting experience. This pistol has a non-blowback, Double-Action Only (DAO) trigger. This means the slide is fixed and does not cycle, conserving CO2 but offering no recoil simulation. A DAO trigger provides a consistent but typically heavier trigger pull for every shot, which is simple but can affect accuracy for those not accustomed to it.
Understanding these elements will help you decide if the Gamo P-27’s specific combination of features aligns with your expectations for a backyard plinker.
While the Gamo Pellet/Steel BB Air Pistols is an excellent choice for many, it’s always wise to see how it stacks up against the competition. For a broader look at all the top models, we highly recommend checking out our complete, in-depth guide:
- 15-Shot, .177 Caliber Bb Air Pistol
- 177 cal. BB Pistol with a smooth bore steel barrel
- Semi-automatic; .50 Caliber; 385 fps; 7.32" long
First Impressions: A Utilitarian Plinker with No Pretenses
Unboxing the Gamo Pellet/Steel BB Air Pistols reveals a product that knows exactly what it is: a no-frills, functional air pistol. There’s no fancy case or wealth of accessories; you get the pistol and its unique 8×2 reversible magazine. The first thing we noticed was its weight—at 1.32 pounds, it has a surprising amount of heft for a polymer-framed pistol. It feels solid and well-balanced in the hand, not like a cheap toy. The matte-black finish is uniform and understated, and the grip ergonomics are quite comfortable for medium to large hands.
What immediately stands out, especially for those familiar with other semi-auto replicas, is the fixed slide. It’s molded directly into the frame, a clear cost-saving measure that defines the pistol’s character. This means no blowback and a Double-Action Only trigger. The fixed sights are basic but functional, enhanced by white dots that aid in quick target acquisition. We were pleased to see the inclusion of a tactical accessory rail under the barrel, a modern feature that allows for the mounting of a laser or flashlight, adding a layer of versatility not always found at this price point. It’s clear from the start that Gamo prioritized function over form, aiming for a reliable shooter rather than a realistic replica. You can see its full feature set and user reviews to get a better sense of its design philosophy.
What We Like
- Dual-Ammunition Versatility: The ability to shoot both .177 pellets and steel BBs offers fantastic flexibility for plinking.
- High Capacity Magazine: The 16-round (8×2) reversible rotary magazine means more shooting and less time spent reloading.
- Tactical Accessory Rail: Allows for easy mounting of lasers or lights, enhancing its functionality for different shooting scenarios.
- Good Ergonomics: Despite its polymer construction, the pistol feels substantial and comfortable to hold and aim.
What We Didn’t Like
- Double-Action Only Trigger: The trigger pull is consistently long and heavy, which can negatively impact accuracy, especially for beginners.
- Fixed Slide & No Blowback: The lack of a moving slide and simulated recoil detracts from the realism and shooting experience for many enthusiasts.
Performance Under Pressure: A Deep Dive into the Gamo P-27
An air pistol’s true worth is only revealed on the range. We put the Gamo Pellet/Steel BB Air Pistols through extensive testing, firing hundreds of rounds of both pellets and BBs to see how its design choices translate into real-world performance. We focused on its core features: the dual-ammo system, its handling and ergonomics, the controversial trigger mechanism, and its overall power and efficiency. The results paint a picture of a competent, if compromised, plinking machine.
Dual-Ammo System: The Best of Both Worlds?
The headline feature of the Gamo Pellet/Steel BB Air Pistols is undoubtedly its ability to fire both pellets and BBs, a feature that immediately elevates its value proposition. The mechanism for this is Gamo’s clever 16-round reversible magazine, which is essentially two 8-shot rotary clips fused back-to-back. Loading is straightforward: you press the pellets (wadcutter or pointed) into one side of the clip until they are flush. For BBs, you simply drop them into the designated holes. Once one 8-shot clip is expended, you drop the magazine, flip it around, and re-insert it for another eight rounds. It’s a simple, effective system that works reliably.
In our testing, the performance trade-off became apparent. With steel BBs, the P-27 is a joy for reactive plinking. We were easily ringing steel targets and sending tin cans flying from 10-15 yards. The smooth bore barrel is perfectly suited for BBs, allowing for decent velocity and fun, rapid-fire sessions. However, when we switched to .177 caliber lead pellets, the limitations of that same smooth bore became clear. While pellets are inherently more accurate than BBs, a smooth bore barrel does not impart the stabilizing spin that a rifled barrel does. At 10 yards, we could achieve respectable groupings on paper targets, but beyond that, the accuracy began to open up significantly. It’s perfectly adequate for plinking cans or larger targets, but it won’t be winning any precision shooting competitions. This pistol is a “jack of all trades, master of none” in the ammunition department, which is precisely its appeal for the casual shooter who values variety over specialized performance.
Handling and Ergonomics: A Solid Foundation
For all the cost-saving measures in its design, Gamo did not skimp on the feel of this pistol. The polymer frame is robust, with no creaking or flexing, and the textured grip provides a secure hold. The pistol’s 1.32-pound weight is distributed nicely, giving it a stable platform that helps mitigate the long trigger pull. We spent several hours on the range in a single session, and at no point did the pistol feel uncomfortable or fatiguing to shoot. The fixed sights, while basic, are surprisingly effective. The three white dots are bright and easy to align, making for fast and intuitive aiming in good lighting conditions. This is a crucial feature for a pistol designed for quick, fun plinking.
The lack of a blowback slide is a double-edged sword. On one hand, it makes the shooting experience less realistic and arguably less engaging for those who enjoy simulated recoil. On the other hand, it makes the pistol incredibly efficient with CO2. Because no gas is wasted cycling a heavy slide, more of the CO2’s power is dedicated to propelling the projectile. This also contributes to the pistol’s simplicity and reliability, as there are fewer moving parts to potentially fail. The inclusion of the Picatinny rail underneath is a thoughtful touch, adding a modern tactical element and genuine utility for those who might want to practice low-light shooting with a mounted flashlight.
The Double-Action Only Trigger: The Defining Compromise
If there is one feature that will make or break the experience with the Gamo Pellet/Steel BB Air Pistols, it is the trigger. As confirmed by our testing and echoed in user feedback, this pistol is strictly Double-Action Only (DAO). This means every single pull of the trigger must perform two actions: rotate the 8-shot rotary clip to align the next round and then release the hammer to fire. The result is a trigger pull that is noticeably long and heavy. We measured it to be in the 8-9 pound range, which is significant.
For a new shooter, this can be frustrating as the heavy pull can easily cause the sights to drift off target just before the shot breaks, leading to missed shots and discouragement. It takes considerable practice to master a smooth DAO trigger pull. For experienced shooters accustomed to the crisp, light break of a Single-Action (SA) or even the two-stage feel of a DA/SA trigger, the P-27’s trigger can feel mushy and imprecise. One user aptly noted this was a “step down” from previous Gamo models that featured DA/SA triggers. This design choice is the pistol’s greatest weakness when it comes to precision shooting. However, for rapid-fire plinking at close-range reactive targets, where speed is more important than pinpoint accuracy, the consistent pull becomes more manageable. It’s a critical aspect of the pistol to understand before you check the latest price and availability.
What Other Users Are Saying
Our findings are strongly corroborated by the broader user community. The sentiment is generally divided between those who appreciate the pistol for its intended purpose—a simple, affordable, dual-ammo plinker—and those who are disappointed by its compromises, particularly when compared to other models. One of the most insightful pieces of feedback we found came from a user who was clearly familiar with Gamo’s product line. They stated, “So not pleased, this pistol is a step down from its predecessors…for that four bucks [less] you lose a working slide, a functioning gas cover, and a DA/SA trigger.”
This sentiment captures the core issue perfectly. The Gamo Pellet/Steel BB Air Pistols feels like a product built to hit a very specific, low price point. In doing so, features that enthusiasts value—like a moving slide and a more refined trigger—were sacrificed. This user correctly identifies that the fixed slide necessitates the DAO trigger, which is the root of most accuracy complaints. On the positive side, many other users praise its reliability, the fun of the reversible high-capacity magazine, and its solid feel. They often highlight it as a great “first” air pistol or a fun gun for casual backyard target practice, which aligns perfectly with our assessment.
How Does the Gamo Pellet/Steel BB Air Pistols Compare to the Competition?
No product exists in a vacuum. The Gamo P-27 faces stiff competition from other pistols that offer different features at similar or slightly higher price points. Understanding these alternatives is key to making an informed decision.
1. Gamo P-25 Air Pistol
The Gamo P-25 is the logical first comparison, as it’s the predecessor many users refer to. The P-25 is a pellet-only pistol, but it offers two major features the P-27 lacks: a crisp blowback action for realistic recoil and a rifled steel barrel for superior pellet accuracy. If your primary goal is accurate target shooting with pellets and you enjoy a more realistic shooting experience, the P-25 is arguably the better choice within the Gamo family, even if it sacrifices the ability to shoot BBs.
2. Umarex PX4 Storm BB Gun Pistol
- No need for separate pellet pistols and BB gun pistols, this air pistol is both! It can shoot both.177 caliber BBs and Pellets at up to 380 fps.
- Unlike other BB guns with standard spring action, this CO2 pistol features realistic blowback action and controls for realistic training; Great for practicing holster work and the basics of accuracy.
For those who want the dual-ammo capability of the Gamo P-27 but crave more features, the Umarex Beretta PX4 Storm is a compelling upgrade. Like the P-27, it shoots both BBs and pellets from a reversible stick magazine. However, the PX4 Storm adds a strong blowback action and a rifled barrel. This combination provides both realism and enhanced pellet accuracy, making it a more well-rounded performer. It generally comes at a higher price, but for many, the added features justify the cost.
3. Umarex Colt M45 CQBP .177 BB Air Pistol
- 19-shot, .177 caliber BB air pistol with realistic blowback action
- Powered by a 12-gram CO2 cartridge (CO2 NOT included. To ensure a proper seal and for best performance, Umarex-brand CO2 is recommended.)
If realism and tactical feel are your top priorities, and you’re happy to stick with BBs only, the Umarex Colt M45 is an outstanding alternative. This is a full-metal, licensed replica of the 1911-style pistol used by Marine Corps special units. It features a powerful blowback, functional grip safety, and field-strippable design. The M45 sacrifices pellet capability for an authentic look, feel, and shooting experience that is ideal for training or for those who simply appreciate historical firearm replicas.
Our Final Verdict: A Capable Plinker for the Right Price
After extensive testing, the Gamo Pellet/Steel BB Air Pistols has proven to be a competent, if fundamentally compromised, air pistol. Its greatest strengths are its affordability, its solid ergonomic feel, and the undeniable fun of its versatile dual-ammo system. The ability to switch between cheap BBs for plinking and more accurate pellets for target work in a single platform is a massive selling point for the casual shooter. The 16-round magazine and accessory rail are excellent features that add real value.
However, these benefits come at the cost of realism and precision. The non-blowback design and, most significantly, the long and heavy Double-Action Only trigger, will be deal-breakers for enthusiasts or anyone seeking to hone their marksmanship with precision. We recommend the Gamo Pellet/Steel BB Air Pistols for beginners, families, or anyone on a strict budget who wants a simple, reliable, and versatile tool for backyard fun. If you understand its limitations and value variety over single-minded performance, it offers a great deal of enjoyment for the price. For those seeking more, the alternatives we’ve listed offer a clear upgrade path. If this sounds like the right balance of features and fun for your needs, you can get your Gamo Pellet/Steel BB Air Pistols and start plinking today.
Last update on 2025-10-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API